The identification of specific nucleic acid sequences by FISH has revealed sites of RNA processing, transport, and cytoplasmic localization (
1). Recognition of these sites of hybridization is possible only when sufficient concentrations of the target sequence provide contrast with regions of lesser or no signal. Here we describe a quantitative approach to identify single molecules in these regions of low concentration. The methodology also facilitates accurate quantitation of the regions containing multiple copies of RNA, such as is found at transcription sites. Analysis of individual transcription sites with single molecule accuracy generated precise information on nascent chain initiation, elongation, and termination.
FISH images are composed of points of light with variable intensities resulting either from hybridization or from background fluorescent noise. We used multiple probes targeted specifically to β-actin mRNA to generate high-intensity point sources that result from hybridization to individual RNAs. We then quantitated the light intensity from each point source to distinguish hybridization events from spurious fluorescence.
The strategy involves (i) synthesizing several oligonucleotide probes to adjacent sequences on an RNA target such that their collective fluorescence will be emitted as a point source after hybridization; (ii) conjugating fluorochromes to specific sites on each oligonucleotide probe so that the fluorescent output per molecule of probe can be calibrated (Fig.
1, A to C); (iii) acquiring digital images from a series of focal planes through a hybridized cell; and (iv) processing these images with a constrained deconvolution algorithm such that out-of-focus light is quantitatively restored to its original points of origin.
To identify single β-actin mRNA molecules, we hybridized multiple probes to the isoform-specific 3′-untranslated region (UTR) of the mRNA in normal rat kidney (NRK) cells. The acquired fluorescence image was made up of numerous bright points of fluorescence interspersed within a diffuse, lower intensity signal (Fig.
1D). After deconvolution, the image consisted of numerous distinct points of light throughout the cytoplasm (Fig.
1E). The brightest points of light were constrained to a few contiguous volume elements (voxels). The image also contained scattered single voxels and clusters of voxels with low amounts of fluorescent signal attributed to low-level autofluorescence and sources of background noise. Establishing an image threshold removed ∼95% of these voxels (Fig.
1, F and G). The discrete, brightest clusters that remained after a threshold was established are referred to as objects. The total fluorescence intensity (TFI) of each object was then calculated. These bright objects had TFI values expected for single molecules and fell within the range of one to five probes hybridized (Fig.
1H). This analysis supports the conclusion that single molecules of β-actin mRNA were being detected and that they corresponded to the points of light. The β-actin mRNA molecules were often far enough apart to be resolved by light microscopy as individual point sources.
Additional evidence that these points of light are single molecules comes from an analysis of their prevalence. A population of cells grown in serum-free medium contained 500 ± 200 β-actin mRNAs per cell. In an exponentially growing population of cells the number increased to ∼1500 copies, consistent with activation of actin mRNA transcription and possible stabilization of cytoplasmic actin mRNA by serum (
2,
3)
. This copy number of β-actin mRNA agrees with estimates of the average abundance of β-actin mRNA per cell derived from molecular techniques (
4).
Finally, spectrally distinct probes hybridized to different target sequences on the same mRNA molecule were used to verify single molecule detection. When the probes were targeted to the same molecule, the signals were close together (Fig.
2C). The TFI confirmed that they were hybridized to only one molecule. Statistical analysis of 478 signals in the cell determined that 59% of the red signals were ≤3 voxels (279 nm) from a green signal. As a control, two isoforms of actin mRNA, β and γ, were detected simultaneously in the same cell with probes that were specific for each isoform (Fig.
2, A and B). The gene sites for each isoform were distinguishable in the nucleus and the mRNAs as separate point sources in the cytoplasm. In contrast to the cis probes, the signals did not colocalize significantly; they were ≤3 voxels apart 13% of the time.
Visualization and measurement of intramolecular distances were possible when the cis probes were sufficiently separated (Fig.
2, C and D). To ascertain that the displacement of the hybridization signal was not an artifact due to misalignment of the respective red and green images, we hybridized three probes, each labeled with distinct fluorochromes, to β-actin mRNA at distances of 1648 nucleotides (nt) (maximum) and 631 nt (minimum) apart. We found that the registered images from the maximally distant probes were not coincident (as much as 487 nm apart), whereas near probes were within the same voxel. This result indicated that the detected mRNA was almost completely extended (1648 kb × 0.3 nm per nucleotide = 494 nm).
To verify that a single copy sequence could be detected by this method, we hybridized 10 probes, each with six CY3 fluorochromes, to the template strand of the β-actin gene (Fig.
3A). Eleven probes, each with five fluorescein isothiocyanate (FITC) fluorochromes, targeted to the β-actin nascent transcripts were used simultaneously (Fig.
3B) and verified the gene site by colocalization (Fig.
3C). The TFI values obtained for hybridization to the single DNA target (60 fluorochromes) were consistent with the TFI predicted from single mRNAs. The nascent transcripts gave a much brighter signal than the gene because they represented multiple RNA molecules concentrated at that site. Measurement of 130 genes revealed the distribution of fluorescence expected from the independent hybridization of 10 probes (Fig.
3D). The hybridization efficiency was close to 100%, because all 10 probes hybridized most frequently. Hybridization to nascent transcripts indicated the presence of multiple copies corresponding to a maximum of 68 probes per transcription site.
This technology allowed us to quantitate the kinetics of β-actin mRNA transcription (Fig.
4). Cells cultured overnight in serum-free medium showed essentially no detectable transcriptional activity (Fig.
4A). The addition of serum (
2) resulted in synchronous activation of transcription detected on one of the β-actin alleles in virtually every cell within a few minutes (Fig.
4B). The number of nascent transcripts per β-actin allele was determined with a single probe to the 5′-UTR. The simultaneous use of 3′-UTR probes provided information on the number of polymerase molecules that had progressed to the terminal portion of the gene. At 3 min after induction, the average gene contained 12 nascent RNAs, but few 3′-UTR signals (Fig.
4, B and G). By 4 min, both β-actin alleles were transcriptionally active in almost all cells, and four transcripts had entered into the 3′-UTR (Fig.
4G). These results are consistent with a transcription rate of 1.1 to 1.4 kb/min (
5). The mean number of nascent transcripts associated with each gene increased linearly from 0 to 5 min, with a mean increase of four transcripts per minute (Fig.
4H). Few transcripts dissociated from the site during this 5-min interval, as evidenced by the probe fluorescence constrained to the location of the gene (Fig.
4C).
Between 5 and 15 min after induction, the number of nascent RNA transcripts per allele increased steadily and peaked at 15 min, with an average of 30 nascent transcripts per allele (Fig.
4H). During the same period, the mean number of transcripts traversing the 3′-UTR reached a steady-state value of 8 to 10, indicating that the rate of entry of new transcripts into this region was equal to the rate of transcripts terminating. At this time, spots of fluorescence were detected around the transcription site (Fig.
4, D and E). These point sources of fluorescence were less intense than the transcription sites. Their TFI values were identical to the points of signal in the cytoplasm; therefore, we interpreted them to be single, terminated transcripts leaving the site of the gene.
Because the released transcripts did not accumulate significantly in the immediate vicinity of the gene after the expected time of termination, we concluded that the initiation of transport took no more than a few minutes. The dispersal of transcripts away from the transcription site took on a variety of spatial patterns (Fig.
4, D and E). Often tracklike distributions were apparent, and the regular spacing between points suggested a constant rate of movement away from the transcription site. Occasionally, the transcripts appeared to spiral away from the site of transcription; however, in at least half of the cases examined, the terminated transcripts simply appeared to diffuse around the site, without any discernible pattern. Nascent transcripts diminished at 60 min after serum induction (Fig.
4F). The decline of transcriptional activity beginning at 30 min fit an exponential decay profile for the next 1.5 hours, at which time it became indistinguishable from the state before induction (Fig.
4H). Over the induction period beginning at 10 min, there was a constant increase in the number of single β-actin mRNA molecules in the cytoplasm (
6).
The capacity of these procedures to generate accurate information about single cells was illustrated by a high-resolution, dynamic view of each β-actin mRNA transcription site obtained with three probes positioned along the RNA, each labeled with a different fluorochrome (Fig.
4I). A “snapshot” of a representative gene revealed 23 nascent RNAs in the process of elongation, 14 of which had progressed through the proximal 3′-UTR and 8 of those through the distal 3′-UTR. At least five of the RNAs had passed the cleavage and polyadenylation site. These RNAs may be nascent, cleaved but undergoing polyadenylation, or awaiting transport. These possibilities should be distinguished by using probes downstream from the cleavage and polyadenylation site. The rat β-actin gene has a consensus “termination” sequence at the predicted distance downstream of the polyadenylation sequence that might account for this observation (
7). The average spacing between polymerases in the 3′-UTR was ∼60 nt, whereas in the 5′-region of the gene, it was ∼170 nt. This spacing is consistent with previous observations on polymerase II (Pol II) transcription loading (
8). The closer packing of polymerases in the 3′-UTR of the gene suggested that termination and release were rate limiting. Recent work indicates that Pol II recruits cleavage and polyadenylation factors, which may result in the polymerase slowing at this point (
9).
The rate of increase (four transcripts per minute) in the number of nascent transcripts from 0 to 5 min reflects solely the rate of initiation, because few polymerases should have reached the termination site, on the basis of the rate of elongation. An in vitro system indicated that Pol II can initiate at a rate of two transcripts per minute (
10). Between 5 and 15 min, when termination was occurring, there was a sustained increase of one nascent RNA per minute. Assuming that the initiation rate remained constant, then the rate of termination and release would be three RNA per minute. Surprisingly, there was a precipitous decrease of activity at the transcription site after 30 min. The cycle of the transcriptional pulse in response to serum is similar to that shown for c-
fos(
11). By interrogating the site with probes along the length of the RNA, we determined that this shut-down resulted from an inhibition of initiation rather than “pausing” of the polymerases. There was no apparent accumulation of transcripts at the nuclear envelope, so it is likely that export is not rate limiting.
The advance herein evaluates FISH images so that single molecule signals are not eliminated through background subtraction or the establishment of a threshold. As a consequence of this approach, single mRNA molecules were detectable with as little as one oligonucleotide probe, containing only five fluorochromes, an increase in sensitivity more than two orders of magnitude greater than previously obtained (
12). In addition, the template DNA strand was accessible to the small probes during transcription without denaturation, contrary to other protocols, and may indicate that it contained single-stranded regions. This technique may therefore allow probing of the active regions of chromatin and facilitate detection of specific genes or groups of genes where only short, nonrepetitive sequences can be used. This would bring many physiologically important genes for receptors, signaling molecules, cell cycle regulators, and transcription factors, as well as their nuclear and cytoplasmic transcripts, into range of FISH detection.